Bakery, Sweets & Cheese Pre-Orders for Pickup
We are now accepting pre-orders. Please follow the steps below to place & pickup your order
We are now accepting pre-orders. Please follow the steps below to place & pickup your order:
- Fill up your cart with all the buckeyes, cheese curds, sweet potato bread & home baked pies
- During checkout, you'll be asked to tell us when you'd like to pick your order up during our hours of operation (listed below). Please give us two days notice.
- Come by and tell the cashier your name and we'll collect your order for you
If you have any questions at all - please call 937-325-0629
The Dairy Store + Farmstead Cheese Marketplace
Dine-In & App Orders
Mon – Thu 11AM – 9PM
Fri 11AM – 10PM
Sat 9AM – 10PM
Sun 9AM – 9PM
Dine-In Breakfast Available
9am-Noon on Saturday & Sunday
Closed Thanksgiving Day, Christmas Eve and Christmas Day
Breads & Sweets
| Image | Name | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 | 4 Pack Buckeyes | $4.75 | |
 | Cinnamon Honey Butter | $2.79 | |
 | Homemade Sweet Potato Bread | $6.25 | |
 | Homemade Mini Sweet Potato Bread | $3.75 | |
 | Homemade Brownies with Pecans | $6.25 | |
 | Pecan Rolls | $3.50 | |
 | Chocolate Chip Cookies | $3.95 | |
 | Buckeye Brownies - 2 Pack | $3.95 |
Cheese Samplers & Cheddar Curds
| Image | Name | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Cajun Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Cheddar Ranch Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Dill Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Garlic Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Italian Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Sweet Basil & Garlic Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | White Cheddar Curds | $8.45 | |
 | Cheddar Curd Sampler (Plain, Italian, Dill, Garlic) | $13.95 | |
 | Cheddar Curd Sampler (Plain, Sweet Basil, Cajun, Garlic) | $13.95 | |
 | Chedda Cheese Crispys | $5.95 | |
 | Baked Cheddar Curds | $5.95 |
9" Homemade Pies
| Name | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin Pie | $10.95 | |
| Apple Pie | $11.75 | |
| Peach Pie | $13.50 | |
| Cherry Pie | $13.50 | |
| Pecan Pie | $14.50 | |
| Blackberry Pie | $14.50 |
